Hiring a Generative Engine Optimization Agency? Read This First
Generative engine optimization, or GEO, has gone from an academic term to a crowded agency category very quickly. Agencies now promise to get your brand recommended by ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude and Perplexity. Some do valuable work. Others repackage basic SEO at a premium, or sell tricks that won’t last.
If you’re considering a generative engine optimization agency, here’s what the work should involve and how to tell the difference.
What GEO actually is
GEO is the work of making your brand visible, and accurately described, in the answers AI assistants give. When someone asks “what’s the best accounting software for a small agency?” or “which mattress brands are good for back pain?”, the assistant builds an answer from what it has learned and, more and more, from live searches. GEO aims to make your brand part of that answer.
It isn’t separate from SEO. The same foundations apply: clear pages that answer real questions, a technically healthy site, structured data and a strong reputation on trusted third-party sites. GEO adds a focus on how assistants interpret and summarise all of that.
How AI visibility should be measured
This is where agencies differ most. A credible approach looks like this:
- A fixed set of buyer questions. Agree on the 30 to 100 questions real buyers in your category ask before they choose.
- Regular checks across assistants. Run those questions through the main assistants on a schedule, and record whether you’re mentioned, how you’re described and who’s recommended instead.
- Accuracy as well as presence. Being mentioned with the wrong price or an outdated product is a problem, not a win.
- Trend over time. AI answers vary from one run to the next, so a single screenshot proves little. Look at the pattern across weeks.
Ask any agency to show you a sample of this reporting before you sign.
What the work itself involves
- Pages that answer buyer questions directly: comparisons, buyer guides, and clear category and product pages.
- Structured data, so your products, prices and reviews are easy for machines to read.
- Digital PR and mentions on sites the assistants trust, from industry publications to review platforms.
- Fixing inaccurate information about your brand wherever it appears online.
- Ongoing traditional SEO, because many assistants draw on search results.
Red flags
- Guarantees. Nobody controls what an AI model says. Anyone who guarantees mentions is overselling.
- Secret techniques. If the method can’t be explained, it probably won’t last.
- No baseline. Work that starts without measuring where you stand can’t prove anything later.
- Content volume for its own sake. Hundreds of thin AI-written pages can drag down your site’s quality.
Questions to ask
- Which buyer questions will you track, and how often?
- How do you measure accuracy, not just mentions?
- What will you change on our site in the first 90 days?
- How do you earn third-party mentions?
- What should we realistically expect by six months?
GEO specialist or full SEO partner?
A GEO specialist may be enough if your SEO foundations are already strong. If your site has technical problems or thin pages, you need a partner who handles SEO and AI visibility together, because the first limits the second.
Choosing well
Ralph Cartwright helps brands get found when buyers ask AI assistants who to buy from or hire, through his advisory firm Connectwright. He sets a baseline of how assistants describe your category, builds a plan for the pages and authority worth earning, and places a partner suited to your site and budget. Then he tracks AI mentions alongside rankings and leads every month. If you’re weighing up GEO agencies, his AI visibility planning starts with a free strategy call. Partners Ralph introduces pay Connectwright a referral fee, and you know that before you sign.

